Citations in-text seem completely random

I changed the ambiguous settings in this one to be a, b and not adding extra authors (both were set, but it seemed that the adding authors was dominant over a,b settings).  

see if it fixes it.  But also check what the publisher requriements are. It maybe that they want additional authors to distinguish multiple publications by the same first author in the same year?  

Chicago 16th Author-Date change ambiguous.zip (2.71 KB)