John,
It was definitely not complying with APA but I found the problem. A few of my citations in older papers were complying but most were not. Papers written before I upgraded to X1 all complied. It looks like my library was corrupted and the carriage return between multiple authors were removed. New citations worked but old ones that came from pre X1 were not.
Now why is it that when I finally get to asking a question (of calling my wife to help me find something) the answer is revealed. Next time I am just going to ask instead of trying to figure it out so that I can figure it out 
.
ShawnÂ