The citation one should be (Author|, Year|, p.^pp. Cited Pages|) (note position of the openning parentheses) so that is what is usually applied when you insert a citation.
and the second one Author (|Year|, p.^pp. Cited Pages|)
The second one is selected only when you “edit citation” and choose the “Author (Year)” version to use as the noun in the text. When editing be sure all spaces are inserted as “link adjacent” except the one between “Cited” and “Pages” (which can be inserted as a field or carefully typed as text).